All orders over $50 ship free! $5 flat rate for anything under!

hi there! I'm jaley

Let me introduce myself:

I grew up with "back to school shopping" involving garage sales and secondhand stores. At the time I didn't know how big of an impact this would eventually have on me, but I'm so grateful that I was exposed to the lifestyle that I've now been blessed to make a living off of. 

If you add my cat and beagle, the girls and guys are split equally in my household. I have a handsome and supportive husband, Kyle, that I couldn't do any of this without. The cutest little boy that I have ever laid eyes on, who might I add, now knows when momma says "we're going shopping" translates to garage sales. Along with a tribe of furbabies. Our dogs, Turbo and Riley, along with a cat, Boo who has been around the longest. 

Along with my stores, I also have a photography business that is very new to me, but is so much fun. It's rare I have free time, but when I'm not busy being a wife, mom, and business owner I love cozying up with a good book or taking my dogs for a walk. 

I may not be rich, but I'm so extremely grateful for the chance to be a small business owner. Every penny you spend goes towards bettering my stores, feeding my family, and giving back. Thank you for supporting my dreams. 

The History of Encore

We have two locations full of fabulous finds for the entire family!

Encore Consignment Shop made its 2005 debut in the small town of Bremen, Indiana under the ownership of Pattie Udstuen. 

The Udstuen family's  dedication to not only the store, but the customers as well, built Encore to be the successful business that so many people have come to love.

In 2018 Pattie decided to retire, leaving her legacy in the hands of Jaley Schinbeckler. With the strong foundation that was already put into place, Jaley is dedicated to ensuring that Encore will continue to grow and thrive for many years to come!

You can stop by our Bremen location at

120 E. Plymouth Street

Bremen, IN 46506


Monday through Friday 1 p.m. to 6 p.m.

Saturday 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.


Our Nappanee store opened just three short years after Bremen, in 2008. Located in Amish country, we're surrounded by quaint shops and eateries!

Find our Nappanee location at

156 S. Main 

Nappanee, IN 46550


Monday through Friday 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.

Saturday 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

With both stores being only about ten minutes apart from each other there are so many things to see and do between the two locations! 

Encore Consignment Shop- Bremen, IN

Encore Consignment Shop- Bremen, IN